Ginger Ale Vs. Ginger Beer

When it comes to crafting cocktails, ginger-based mixers are some of the most versatile and flavorful ingredients a bartender can use. Two of the most commonly confused yet distinct options are ginger ale and ginger beer. While they share a similar spicy-sweet profile, these two beverages differ significantly in taste, production, and best cocktail applications. Understanding these nuances can elevate your mixology skills and enhance your cocktail creations.

Origins and Production:

• Ginger Beer originated in the 18th century in England as an alcoholic beverage, created through the fermentation of ginger, sugar, and water. Traditional ginger beer contained around 2-11% alcohol by volume (ABV). Today, most commercial ginger beers are non-alcoholic but still retain a bold and robust ginger flavor due to their fermentation process. This gives them a cloudy appearance and a complex, slightly yeasty taste.

• Ginger Ale, on the other hand, was developed in the 19th century and is a carbonated soft drink rather than a fermented beverage. It is typically made by combining carbonated water, ginger flavoring (natural or artificial), and sweeteners. Unlike ginger beer, ginger ale is usually clear and has a lighter, milder taste with more sweetness than spice.

Taste and Carbonation

The key difference between ginger ale and ginger beer is their taste and level of carbonation.

• Ginger Beer has an intense ginger kick, often with a fiery, spicy aftertaste due to the fermentation process and the use of real ginger. It is less carbonated than ginger ale, giving it a smoother mouthfeel.

• Ginger Ale is lighter, sweeter, and more effervescent. It lacks the strong, spicy heat of ginger beer, making it a more refreshing and subtly flavored mixer.

  
  

Best Uses in Cocktails

The choice between ginger ale and ginger beer can dramatically change the profile of a cocktail. Here’s when to use each:

• Ginger Beer Cocktails: Due to its bold ginger presence and rich complexity, ginger beer is the preferred choice for cocktails that require a strong, spicy element. Some classic cocktails using ginger beer include:

  
  

  • Moscow Mule – Vodka, lime juice, and ginger beer served in a copper mug.

  • Dark ‘n’ Stormy – Dark rum and ginger beer with a squeeze of lime.

  • Kentucky Mule – A bourbon-based variation of the Moscow Mule.

  • Penicillin – A smoky scotch cocktail that sometimes incorporates ginger beer for added spice.

    
    

• Ginger Ale Cocktails: Ginger ale’s lighter, sweeter profile makes it ideal for more delicate, effervescent cocktails where ginger is not the dominant flavor. Some examples include:

  
  

  • Whiskey Ginger – Whiskey and ginger ale, often served with a lemon or lime garnish.

  • Pimm’s Cup – A refreshing cocktail made with Pimm’s No. 1, ginger ale, and fresh fruit.

  • Shandy – Beer mixed with ginger ale for a light, crisp beverage.

  • Gin Buck – Gin, lemon juice, and ginger ale for a refreshing highball.

    
    

Can You Substitute One for the Other?

While ginger ale and ginger beer both contain ginger, they are not always interchangeable. If a cocktail specifically calls for ginger beer, using ginger ale will result in a much sweeter and milder drink, lacking the depth and spice that ginger beer provides. Conversely, if a recipe calls for ginger ale and you substitute ginger beer, expect a stronger, spicier drink that might overpower the other ingredients. However, in some cases—such as a Moscow Mule versus a Vodka Ginger Highball—swapping one for the other can create an interesting variation.

The prices

The prices for ginger ale and ginger beer can vary depending on the brand, region, and whether it's purchased in a store or online. However, here’s a general price range:

• Ginger Ale:

  • 12-pack (12 oz cans): $4–$7 USD / €3.50–€6.50 EUR

  • Single bottle (12 oz): $1.50–$3 USD / €1.40–€2.80 EUR

• Ginger Beer:

  • 6-pack (12 oz bottles): $7–$12 USD / €6.50–€11 EUR

  • Single bottle (12 oz): $2–$4 USD / €2–€3.50 EUR

These prices can fluctuate based on location and any special promotions or discounts.

Choosing the Right One for Your Bar

For home bartenders and mixologists looking to stock their bar, it’s a good idea to keep both ginger ale and ginger beer on hand. If you enjoy crafting cocktails with a strong, spicy kick, opt for a high-quality ginger beer. If you prefer a lighter, more refreshing mixer, ginger ale is a great choice. Many premium brands offer both options, with variations in sweetness and intensity, so it’s worth experimenting to find the perfect match for your favorite drinks.

Conclusion

Ginger ale and ginger beer may seem similar at first glance, but their differences in production, taste, and application in cocktails make them unique in the world of mixology. Whether you prefer the fiery spice of ginger beer or the crisp sweetness of ginger ale, understanding these distinctions will help you craft better cocktails and appreciate the complexity of each mixer.

For more articles about homemade ingredients click HERE

and stay up to date subscribing to our newsletter HERE