How to Make a Shrub: Easy Drinking Vinegar Syrup for Beginners

Shrub is a sweet and tart syrup made with fruit, sugar, and vinegar. It is used like a flavor concentrate. Add a small amount to soda for an instant non-alcoholic drink, or use it in cocktails as a fast way to build fruit, acidity, and aroma in one ingredient.

Unlike fresh juice, shrub can be prepared ahead and held in the refrigerator, which makes it useful for service. The key is balance: enough sugar to round the vinegar, and enough acid to keep the fruit bright instead of jammy.

Beginner quick guide

• Shrub is fruit + sugar + vinegar, used as a concentrated mixer

• Start with a cold method for the freshest fruit flavor

• Choose vinegar like choosing a spirit: each type has a distinct taste

• A reliable serving start point is 15 to 30 ml shrub per drink

• For soda, try 30 ml shrub plus 120 to 150 ml chilled sparkling water

• Keep shrubs refrigerated and clearly labeled with prep date

• Do not judge safety by tasting, use clean tools and discard if mold appears

• Make small test batches first, then scale once the ratio fits the menu

What is a shrub

In modern bar use, “shrub” usually means a fruit preserve made with vinegar, sweetened with sugar, then used in drinks. It is sometimes called “drinking vinegar”. Many guides frame it as a way to preserve fruit flavor beyond the peak season, while creating a mixer that can cut through ice and dilution.

Historically, the word “shrub” has also been used for alcoholic cordials in older English usage, so context matters. For cocktails today, shrub almost always refers to the vinegar-based style.

What shrub tastes like and why bartenders use it

A well-made shrub tastes like bright fruit up front, a clean sweet mid-palate, and a crisp acidic finish. The vinegar is not supposed to taste aggressive. It should feel like a structured tartness, closer to a sour candy snap than a salad dressing.

Why it works behind a bar:

• It replaces multiple steps: fruit flavor, acid, and sweetener are combined

• It helps low-proof and non-alcoholic drinks feel “grown up”

• It adds complexity fast, especially with aged spirits and bitter aperitifs

• It is easy to batch and consistent when measured

The 3 building blocks: fruit, sugar, vinegar

Fruit

Use ripe, aromatic fruit. Avoid fruit that is watery and bland. If fruit is weak, shrub will taste thin no matter how good the vinegar is.

Good beginner fruits:

• Strawberry, raspberry, blackberry

• Peach, pineapple, mango

• Apple, pear

• Citrus can work, but needs careful peel handling to avoid bitterness

Sugar

Sugar controls body and smoothness. Too little sugar makes the vinegar sharp. Too much makes the drink heavy and “sticky”.

Options:

• White sugar: clean, neutral, most predictable

• Demerara or light brown sugar: warmer notes, good with apple, pear, peach

• Honey: floral, but can mute bright fruit if overused

Vinegar

Vinegar is the “spine” of shrub. The wrong vinegar can dominate. The right vinegar supports the fruit.

Vinegar pairing cheat sheet

• Apple cider vinegar: broad, fruity, beginner-friendly (berries, apple, pear)

• Champagne vinegar: light, clean, elegant (berries, stone fruit)

• White wine vinegar: crisp, neutral (peach, apricot, herbs)

• Rice vinegar: soft acidity (tropical fruit, ginger, tea notes)

• Balsamic: intense, dark sweetness (strawberry, cherry, fig)

• Sherry vinegar: nutty, savory edge (stone fruit, spices, briny twists)

Two core methods: cold method and hot method

Both methods work. The cold method keeps fruit fresh. The hot method is faster and can pull deeper cooked notes.

Method 1: Cold method (best for bright fruit)

1. Combine fruit and sugar, then let it sit covered in the refrigerator

2. The sugar draws out juice, creating an oleo-fruity syrup

3. Strain, then add vinegar to the syrup

4. Bottle, label, refrigerate

Pros:

• Freshest aroma

• Clearer fruit notes

Cons:

• Takes time (usually overnight)

Method 2: Hot method (best for fast service prep)

1. Warm fruit and sugar gently to dissolve sugar and extract juice

2. Cool completely

3. Strain, then add vinegar

4. Bottle, label, refrigerate

Pros:

• Fast

• Works well for firm fruit and spice builds

Cons:

• More “jammy” character

• Heat can flatten delicate aromas

How to use shrub in drinks (reliable ratios)

Shrub is a concentrate. Treat it like a syrup plus acid.

Non-alcoholic and highball use

• Start point: 30 ml shrub + 120 to 150 ml sparkling water over ice

• Add a pinch of salt or 2 dashes of aromatic bitters for complexity (optional)

• Garnish should match the shrub: herb sprig, citrus peel, or fruit

Cocktail use

Shrub can replace part of the sweetener and part of the acid.

Starting points:

• Spirit-forward stirred drinks: 10 to 20 ml shrub

• Shaken sours: 15 to 25 ml shrub, then reduce added citrus accordingly

• Long drinks: 15 to 30 ml shrub, then top with soda or tonic

Practical example logic:

• If shrub is sharp, reduce it and add a touch more simple syrup

• If shrub is sweet, increase it slightly and reduce other sweeteners

Quality control and storage SOP (beginner-safe)

Shrub is not automatically shelf-stable just because it contains vinegar. Treat it like a perishable prep unless a formal food safety plan says otherwise.

Basic QC tools that improve consistency

• pH meter: measures acidity level for tracking and repeatability

• Refractometer: measures Brix, which estimates sugar concentration and helps standardize body

A common working target for many bar shrubs is a syrup around 30 Brix, then balanced with vinegar to taste. The “right” number depends on fruit, vinegar strength, and intended use, so treat Brix as a consistency tool, not a universal rule.

pH and safety, without false certainty

pH matters because many pathogens struggle to grow in sufficiently acidic foods. In US food guidance, pH 4.6 is the key cutoff used to define low-acid versus acidified foods. That does not automatically mean a homemade shrub is “safe forever”. Time, refrigeration, sanitation, and cross-contamination risk still matter.

A practical bar approach:

• Refrigerate shrubs

• Use clean, sanitized containers

• Label with prep date

• Set a conservative shelf life window

• Re-check pH periodically if the program depends on it

• Discard immediately if mold appears

Storage checklist

• Store in sealed food-grade bottles

• Keep refrigerated at 4°C or colder

• Label: name, date, batch ID, allergens, intended shelf life

• Use clean funnels and strainers

• Do not taste a product to decide if it is safe

• If mold appears, discard the entire batch

Recipes and measurements

Recipe Card: Strawberry Basil Shrub (cold method)

Yield: about 500 ml (16.9 oz) shrub

Time: 15 minutes active, 12 to 24 hours rest

Technique: cold maceration, strain, acidify

Glassware: for serving, highball or rocks glass

Ingredients

Strawberries, hulled: 300 g (10.6 oz)

Granulated sugar (white caster): 300 g (10.6 oz)

Apple cider vinegar: 250 ml (8.5 oz)

Fresh basil: 10 leaves (optional)

Method

1. Lightly crush the strawberries in a bowl or container. Add sugar and basil. Stir.

2. Cover and refrigerate 12 to 24 hours. Stir once or twice if possible.

3. Strain through a fine strainer. Press gently. Do not force pulp through.

4. Measure the syrup. Add vinegar, starting with 200 ml (6.8 oz). Taste, then adjust up to 250 ml (8.5 oz) for a brighter finish.

5. Bottle, label, refrigerate.

Garnish standard

• Basil sprig or a thin strawberry slice for soda service

• Lemon peel works if the shrub is very sweet

Dilution and temperature notes

• Serve very cold. Shrub tastes sharper at warm temperatures.

• For soda: 30 ml (1 oz) shrub + 120 to 150 ml (4 to 5 oz) sparkling water over ice.

Tasting notes

• Bright strawberry nose, soft sweetness, crisp apple-cider finish

• Basil should sit in the background, not dominate

Batching or prep notes

• For service, pre-bottle in squeeze bottles and keep refrigerated

• Shake the bottle before service if minor separation occurs

Ingredient substitutions and acceptable swaps

• Strawberries: raspberries or blackberries work with the same method

• Apple cider vinegar: champagne vinegar for a lighter finish

• Basil: mint, tarragon, or a small piece of ginger (ginger pairs well with berries)

• White sugar: demerara for a warmer flavor, especially with peach or pear

• For a darker profile: replace part of the vinegar with balsamic, but start small because it can dominate

Common mistakes and fixes

1. Too sharp, vinegar dominates

   Fix: add 5 to 10 percent more sugar to the syrup, or reduce vinegar next batch.

2. Too sweet, tastes flat in drinks

   Fix: increase vinegar slightly or add a small amount of fresh citrus when mixing the drink.

3. Cloudy and gritty

   Fix: strain twice. Avoid forcing pulp through. Let it settle and decant.

4. Fruit flavor feels weak

   Fix: use riper fruit, extend maceration time, or add a small amount of zest (avoid too much pith).

5. Off aroma or visible mold

   Fix: discard the whole batch. Improve sanitation, use clean bottles, refrigerate, shorten holding time.

6. Separation in the bottle

   Fix: normal with some fruit. Shake before use, or strain more

   
   

Explore more recipes and builds in the Homemade Ingredients page

Subscribe for new tools, recipes, and templates in the Newsletter

Written by: Riccardo Grechi | Head Mixologist, Bar Consultant & Trainer