From First Drink to Regular: How Bars Really Build Guest Loyalty

On a rainy Tuesday a guest walks in, orders “just one drink” and sits quietly at the bar.Six months later, the same guest knows half the team by name, brings friends, and texts ahead to check if there’s space.

That transformation—from stranger to regular—is not magic. It’s design.

Guest loyalty doesn’t come from vibes alone, or from one superstar bartender “good with people”. It comes from a pattern of small, repeatable behaviours that any well-run bar can train, track and protect.

This guide breaks loyalty down into concrete steps you can apply tomorrow, whether you run a tiny neighbourhood bar or a 5-star lobby.

1. Think in “Lifetime”, Not “Tonight”

Most bars still play a one-night game: upsell the premium pour, push the special, close the check high.

A loyalty mindset flips the main question:

“What can I do tonight so this guest wants to come back next week?”

That changes your decisions:

• You might not push the most expensive bottle if you sense budget anxiety.

• You invest 30 seconds to explain the menu instead of just dropping it.

• You offer a small taste of something new instead of forcing a hard upsell.

Tonight’s check might be slightly lower.But you’re building trust, and trust is the currency regulars pay with again and again.

2. The First 10 Minutes Decide the Second Visit

Most loyalty is decided before the first drink is finished. Treat the first 10 minutes like a spec:

a. Entry and greeting

• Eye contact within 5 seconds.

• Acknowledgement even if the bar is full.

• “We’re full” always paired with an option:“We’re full right now, but if you’d like to wait I can probably seat you in about 15 minutes.”

  
  

b. Seating and orientation

• One sentence that frames the concept:“We work mostly with classics and seasonal signatures; I’ll be back in a minute if you want help choosing.”

• Water within 2 minutes (aligned with your style: filtered, still, or sparkling).

  
  

c. First recommendation

• One focused question:“Do you feel more fresh and citrusy, or rich and spirit-forward tonight?”

• Two options, not five. Too many choices kill momentum.

If those first 10 minutes feel guided and calm, the guest files your bar under: “Safe place. I know how this works. I can come back.”

3. Recognition Beats Perfection

Regulars don’t come back because every drink is the best of their life. They come back because they feel seen.

Techniques to remember guests without being creepy

1. Use the POS + a regulars log

   • Create a simple tag in your POS or a shared note:“Anna – Negroni, no orange; Thu/Fri after 21:00; 90s hip-hop.”

   • Scan 2–3 names before each shift.

     
     

   Sample POS note template

   • Name / nickname

   • Default drink / style

   • Frequency (days / time range)

   • One personal detail (job / neighbourhood / favourite artist)

   • Allergies / hard no’s

     
     

2. Name + drink + one detail - That’s your minimum memory set:

   • “Good to see you, Anna. Negroni with no orange again, or are we changing mood tonight?”

     
     

3. Stay on the right side of recognition

   • Good: “Nice to see you again, same Daiquiri or something new?”

   • Bad: “Anna, second double Mezcal Last Word this week, right?” – that feels like surveillance.

When you inevitably make a small mistake, being recognised often matters more than perfect execution. Being treated like a stranger after five visits is what really kills loyalty.

4. Design the Experience for Repeat Visits, Not Just Instagram

Over-engineered drinks, massive garnishes and specs that only work on a quiet Monday might look great in photos—but they’re fragile when the bar is full.

A loyalty-friendly menu has:

• Anchor drinks: 6–8 core cocktails that never leave the list and are always executed perfectly. These become “their drink.”

• Rotating curiosity: Seasonal sections, limited-run drinks or a “Bartender’s Lab” slot that changes weekly. Regulars return to see what’s new.

• A “just make me something” option: Dealer’s Choice / Bartender’s Choice for guests who don’t want to think. Over time this becomes a personalised dialogue.

• Plain language: Guests should understand 80% of the menu at a glance. Inside jokes and obscure references belong in staff briefing, not in every line of copy.

Ask: If someone loves us, what reason do they give a friend to come back in two weeks?Your menu should contain that reason clearly.

5. Create Micro-Rituals That Are Yours

Rituals turn a random visit into their place.

Examples:

• Welcome ritual

  • Tiny low-ABV spritz or flavoured water for guests seated at the bar before a certain time.

  • Workflow: poured in batch from a small bottle, 2–3 seconds of labour.

  • Cost: a few cents, perceived value much higher.

• Goodbye ritual

  • A small cordial, housemade tea or NA digestif sample.

  • Or a simple, sincere: “Thank you for coming back, we really appreciate it.”

• Regulars’ ritual

  • Regulars taste R&D drinks before they hit the menu.

  • First access to special events or limited bottles.

Rituals only count if they’re consistent and sustainable. If you only do them when you’re in a great mood, they’re not rituals—they’re mood swings.

6. Use Data and Contact Points Without Killing the Magic

You don’t need a corporate CRM to be smart. You just need a way to keep the conversation going.

Reservations

• Note: birthday, anniversary, “loves smoky flavours”, “allergic to nuts”.

• Check those notes in a 2-minute pre-service briefing.

Social media

• If a guest tags you in a story, reply:“Thank you for coming! Next time you’re in, tell us you’re back—we’d love to mix you something new.”

Mailing list or close group

• Send only things that feel like an advantage:

  • New menu previews

  • Early access to special nights

  • Limited tasting events

The point is not volume of messages, but the feeling of belonging to a smaller inner circle.

7. Loyalty Is a Team Sport, Not a Star Bartender Show

Many bars depend on one charismatic personality. When that person leaves, half the regulars disappear with them.

If you want bar loyalty, not fan clubs:

• Train every team member to recognise faces and use names.

• Share regulars’ notes in briefing:

  • “Table 4 is the couple who loved low-ABV drinks last week; he doesn’t drink gin.”

• Rotate regulars between bartenders:“Tonight Sara will take care of you; she does great agave twists.”

You want guests who say: “I love that bar”, not just “I love that one bartender.”

8. Boundaries: Not Every Frequent Guest Should Be a Regular

Some “regulars” hurt your bar more than they help:

• They drain staff energy.

• They make other guests uncomfortable.

• They expect endless comps.

• They occupy key seats for hours on peak nights with minimal spend.

Real loyalty is mutual. You’re not obligated to reward bad behaviour just because it’s repeated.

Practical moves:

• De-prioritise problem guests on busy nights—no prime seats reserved for energy vampires.

• Limit comps with a clear standard:“We’re happy to treat you now and then, but tonight we need to keep service fair for everyone.”

• Act quickly if someone crosses boundaries with staff or other guests.

Protecting your team and atmosphere is the ultimate loyalty move—for the right guests.

9. From Vibes to Systems

At The Double Strainer we often talk about guest experience, atmosphere and storytelling—and that absolutely matters for loyalty. But the real step-change happens when you connect those ideas to concrete systems:

• Notes in the POS that any team member can read and use.

• Short, structured briefings where regulars, events and priorities are shared.

• Codified rituals that happen every night, not just when the head bartender feels like it.

• Clear filters for “bad regulars” so your best guests and your team stay protected.

The classic blind spot of creative bars is believing that loyalty is born from one charismatic bartender or a single “magic” night. In reality, durable loyalty comes from small, repeatable behaviours that survive staff turnover, concept changes and your bad days behind the stick.

10. A 3-Minute Briefing and a One-Week Experiment

To turn this article into action, try this for the next seven days:

3-minute pre-service briefing

1. Regulars & reservations (1 minute)

   • Name, face, favourite style, any notes for 2–3 guests likely to appear.

2. Focus drinks (1 minute)

   • Anchor drink to push for regulars.

   • One rotating / experimental drink to offer as a taste or suggestion.

3. Ritual check (1 minute)

   • Welcome or goodbye ritual everyone will execute tonight.

   • Who is responsible for batching / prep.

     
     

One-week experiment

Pick one of these and commit for a week:

• Log every potential regular in the POS with name + drink + one detail.

• Execute the same welcome ritual for every bar-seat guest before 9 pm.

• Do the 3-minute briefing before each service and review what worked on day 7.

At the end of the week, check:

• Did you recognise more faces?

• Did conversations pick up faster?

• Did a guest explicitly say “I’ll be back” or bring someone?

That’s loyalty in its real form: not a points card, but a pattern of people who choose your bar again.

Written by Riccardo Grechi

 Head Mixologist | Bar Concept Developer | Founder of The Double Strainer

For more articles about mixology knowledge click HERE

and stay up to date subscribing to our newsletter HERE